Interesting idea. But are you sure that we WEIRDos actually do have the best bullshit? I grew up in non-WEIRD countries, and I remember they also had some real weapons-grarde bullshit there. Could it be that it just looks that way to us because we implicitly assume that the W, the E, the I, the R, and the D aspects would naturally lead us to *not* produce as much BS, and then the fact that BS is in fact abundant in our culture just is more salient than if a non-WEIRD culture produced BS?
Love the phrase “weapons grade bullshit”. Yea to answer your question, I’m not sure, and I wanted to put the idea out there to see how plausible people found it. So I could be wrong, and your anecdotal data is starting to make me think that. In any case, the hypothesis is more about the quality of bullshit than the quantity. I suspect WEIRD bullshit is more “advanced”, in the same way WEIRD technology is more advanced. Like our bullshit is more effectively designed to flatter, cajole, persuade, excuse, justify, etc. Does that ring true to you? Do people seem like smoother talkers now than when you grew up? Maybe our bullshit is subtler and harder to detect?
I think you are on to something there. The WEIRD bullshit *exploits* our education etc. I'm sure you have read Harry Frankfurt's famous essay / booklet "On Bullshit"? He gives the perfect definition that is compatible with the idea that BS *sounds* true and sophisticated. But still I am not convinced that there is a fundamental difference between WEIRD and non-WEIRD BS.
Yes, I've read Frankfurt and am a big fan. Perhaps "fundamental" difference is too strong, but it seems we can agree there are at least some interesting differences between WEIRD and non-WEIRD bullshit that are worthy of further reflection. Thanks for reading, and thanks for your thoughts.
I agree with you on the advancement of bullshit. Like the humans on the giving and receiving end of it, bullshit has evolved over time. And yes, I would think it is more subtle out of its own survival instinct (for lack of a better term). If we all saw the bullshit, it would cease to exist. It has become more subtle and, dare I say, nefarious as human advancement makes the older propagation of bullshit obvious. And I hypothesize it will grow more so over time - at some point reaching near imperceptibility.
>>To all the anthropologists and world travelers out there, I’m genuinely curious: do non-WEIRD cultures share our most advanced forms of bullshit?
I made up a theory that is kind of the opposite of that question: In the beginning, any bullshit that could keep people together was good enough. Only after immense amounts of cultural evolution, societies where not only bullshit, but also advanced technology kept people together took shape.
For tens of thousands of years, what mattered most was how well people could cooperate. People who could form bigger groups and then bigger armies won and people who could not cooperate that well lost. That means that the most socially cohesive bullshit made societies win. Only much later, those societies that could build ships and make cannons won over those who couldn't. Only then it made sense to make up systems that weren't totally, thoroughly based on bullshit.
Interesting! I buy it. I especially like Henrich's theory of monogamy as a culturally selected trait that's useful for intergroup competition. Of course, with monogamy comes its own package of bullshit about "soulmates" and the like. Perhaps I'll write about that at some point.
You are really onto something here. America is a really strange place, when compared to other countries where I have traveled extensively. I general, I find that people are more genuinely happy elsewhere despite simpler lifestyles and less ambitious goals. I often find myself subconsciously apologizing for many aspects of American culture, even though I love this country and probably wouldn’t choose to live anywhere else. Just being aware of our special type of bullshit is very enlightening to me, because it helps me put into context the things I love and hate about this country and how to make it better where I can. That’s all, sorry for all the bullshit :)
> Do they think morality is about being nice and making the world a better place?
Almost certainly not. There's an old story about a Hottentot telling a missioner: "Good is when I take my neighbors' cow, bad is when my neighbor takes mine".
Related: Anthropologists, who want to learn things about other people, tend to be Anglospheric and German. Some French and other Europeans. Other nations want to know about the WEIRD people, but it is for advantage. The Thai aren't much curious about the Bolivians and the Inuit, and vice versa.
Bullshit expands to fill the space available. For example 21st c 24/7 'news' sites (BBC CNN etc) contain no more real news than they did when they were just half an hour long. And as for tv 'entertainment'
Well , don,t you think individualistic ( America ) countries will have more bullshit as compared to a having collectivistic culture ( Japan ) .Common bullshit for common society 🥅
America is the richest society in human history . There are some people who are like zillionaire and just below in hierarchy are way below ( academics , journalist , other cultural elite ) , tend to very envious of these people which results in producing ample amount of BS
Thanks so much for sharing, Brian. This is really interesting. It seems like a few of the points I made about WEIRD bullshit are ringing true—the denial of our status motive, the pretending to want happiness (over and above wanting to be already happy), the pretending to not care what others think, and the desire to make the world a better place. It seems like these are pretty WEIRD forms of bullshit. But it seems like the other forms of bullshit are not so WEIRD, and that there may not be *less* bullshit here so much as different kinds of it. Lots to chew on. Thanks again for sharing and thanks for reading.
Interesting idea. But are you sure that we WEIRDos actually do have the best bullshit? I grew up in non-WEIRD countries, and I remember they also had some real weapons-grarde bullshit there. Could it be that it just looks that way to us because we implicitly assume that the W, the E, the I, the R, and the D aspects would naturally lead us to *not* produce as much BS, and then the fact that BS is in fact abundant in our culture just is more salient than if a non-WEIRD culture produced BS?
Love the phrase “weapons grade bullshit”. Yea to answer your question, I’m not sure, and I wanted to put the idea out there to see how plausible people found it. So I could be wrong, and your anecdotal data is starting to make me think that. In any case, the hypothesis is more about the quality of bullshit than the quantity. I suspect WEIRD bullshit is more “advanced”, in the same way WEIRD technology is more advanced. Like our bullshit is more effectively designed to flatter, cajole, persuade, excuse, justify, etc. Does that ring true to you? Do people seem like smoother talkers now than when you grew up? Maybe our bullshit is subtler and harder to detect?
I think you are on to something there. The WEIRD bullshit *exploits* our education etc. I'm sure you have read Harry Frankfurt's famous essay / booklet "On Bullshit"? He gives the perfect definition that is compatible with the idea that BS *sounds* true and sophisticated. But still I am not convinced that there is a fundamental difference between WEIRD and non-WEIRD BS.
Yes, I've read Frankfurt and am a big fan. Perhaps "fundamental" difference is too strong, but it seems we can agree there are at least some interesting differences between WEIRD and non-WEIRD bullshit that are worthy of further reflection. Thanks for reading, and thanks for your thoughts.
I agree with you on the advancement of bullshit. Like the humans on the giving and receiving end of it, bullshit has evolved over time. And yes, I would think it is more subtle out of its own survival instinct (for lack of a better term). If we all saw the bullshit, it would cease to exist. It has become more subtle and, dare I say, nefarious as human advancement makes the older propagation of bullshit obvious. And I hypothesize it will grow more so over time - at some point reaching near imperceptibility.
Like the phenomena described in The Rebel Sell? Hard to imagine they don’t mostly arise in WEIRD societies.
Your work has the same vibe as Sapolsky’s stuff. It’s a compliment, lol
I’m a fan of sapolsky so I do take it as a compliment. Thank you!
>>To all the anthropologists and world travelers out there, I’m genuinely curious: do non-WEIRD cultures share our most advanced forms of bullshit?
I made up a theory that is kind of the opposite of that question: In the beginning, any bullshit that could keep people together was good enough. Only after immense amounts of cultural evolution, societies where not only bullshit, but also advanced technology kept people together took shape.
https://woodfromeden.substack.com/p/a-theory-of-the-bullshitting-class
For tens of thousands of years, what mattered most was how well people could cooperate. People who could form bigger groups and then bigger armies won and people who could not cooperate that well lost. That means that the most socially cohesive bullshit made societies win. Only much later, those societies that could build ships and make cannons won over those who couldn't. Only then it made sense to make up systems that weren't totally, thoroughly based on bullshit.
Interesting! I buy it. I especially like Henrich's theory of monogamy as a culturally selected trait that's useful for intergroup competition. Of course, with monogamy comes its own package of bullshit about "soulmates" and the like. Perhaps I'll write about that at some point.
You are really onto something here. America is a really strange place, when compared to other countries where I have traveled extensively. I general, I find that people are more genuinely happy elsewhere despite simpler lifestyles and less ambitious goals. I often find myself subconsciously apologizing for many aspects of American culture, even though I love this country and probably wouldn’t choose to live anywhere else. Just being aware of our special type of bullshit is very enlightening to me, because it helps me put into context the things I love and hate about this country and how to make it better where I can. That’s all, sorry for all the bullshit :)
> Do they think morality is about being nice and making the world a better place?
Almost certainly not. There's an old story about a Hottentot telling a missioner: "Good is when I take my neighbors' cow, bad is when my neighbor takes mine".
Related: Anthropologists, who want to learn things about other people, tend to be Anglospheric and German. Some French and other Europeans. Other nations want to know about the WEIRD people, but it is for advantage. The Thai aren't much curious about the Bolivians and the Inuit, and vice versa.
Bullshit expands to fill the space available. For example 21st c 24/7 'news' sites (BBC CNN etc) contain no more real news than they did when they were just half an hour long. And as for tv 'entertainment'
https://grahamcunningham.substack.com/p/non-binary-sibling-is-entertaining
Well , don,t you think individualistic ( America ) countries will have more bullshit as compared to a having collectivistic culture ( Japan ) .Common bullshit for common society 🥅
America is the richest society in human history . There are some people who are like zillionaire and just below in hierarchy are way below ( academics , journalist , other cultural elite ) , tend to very envious of these people which results in producing ample amount of BS
Thanks so much for sharing, Brian. This is really interesting. It seems like a few of the points I made about WEIRD bullshit are ringing true—the denial of our status motive, the pretending to want happiness (over and above wanting to be already happy), the pretending to not care what others think, and the desire to make the world a better place. It seems like these are pretty WEIRD forms of bullshit. But it seems like the other forms of bullshit are not so WEIRD, and that there may not be *less* bullshit here so much as different kinds of it. Lots to chew on. Thanks again for sharing and thanks for reading.