Discussion about this post

User's avatar
ALEKOS's avatar

I think you are absolutely right about this currently, but I am not so sure that this was true in the hunter-gatherer era, or later, at least until the medieval period. Back then you really had to believe, because your survival depended on it. The status game wasn't like it is now—you just followed the rules, whatever they were, without question. Now the situation is completely different: we have to hold pseudobeliefs in order to be able to change them more often, because our well-being depends on it. We play this game, for example, to sell our products, stocks, crypto and so on, and in the case of the job environment, we have to be performatively woke to get the job. But conditions and timelines change quickly, so we must be ready to pivot when the time comes. Hence the pseudobeliefs. I don't know, I am thinking about it.

Patstick's avatar

Great essay. But the point about rich leftists "pseudo believing" that rich people should pay more is weak. You can genuinely believe that ALL rich people (including yourself) should pay more tax, as that would radically change society through more welfare provision. But if just one rich person pays extra tax on their own, nothing changes in society, they just get poorer. It's a completely rational position to want all rich people to pay more tax while not writing cheques on your own to the government.

116 more comments...

Ready for more?